Can You Have Sex with a Friend? Or, that Time I Did

29thDec. × ’10

I met Beau through “the scene”–which made the city feel small. Everyone knew everyone, enmeshing casually, gender-lessly– in clubs, alleys, in piles of melted bodies on e. What we knew of each other was little more than myspace profiles. We were our myspace profiles walking around at parties. You didn’t penetrate that.

But Beau became real. He had become a best friend–hanging out at my apartment or going out dancing with my group of girl-friends then crashing at one of our places–his body on the couch curled upside down like a snake.

But then late,  in a drunk cab his hands were running through my hair, twisted and knotted in my lap. The guy who goes from “just friend” to more is especially confusing when you are single– our guard is down. We’ve already put you in the platonic box…now we’ve got to reassess?

You can fuck your friends. Mostly as the star guest in a threesome or during 4 a.m. naked-twister. It’s knowing what you want out of it, being honest as that shifts.

I don’t remember much–being in his bed, the shadow of drunk sex. The next morning we woke up with the high, the whimsy of each other’s bodies. Beau grabbed his phone. “Stay still–I have to take your picture. I need to prove this happened.”

But this won’t change things, we said. We were still friends. But  sometimes at 4 a.m. I’d end up at his place. I was sitting on the floor, eating a  jumbo-slice of pizza. He crawled over then lifted my dress, nestling his face under the crinoline. This probably should have been one of those: what are we doing here moments. Instead I thought: Should I put down the slice of pizza? Can I eat a little more while he is under there– or would that be rude?

The nights turned into weekends: we drank PBR in the shower, he bought breakfasts and treasures from yard sales. It was that haze of summer where sunsets become stiflingly beautiful, somehow causing the days to melt silkily into one and other. But we were trying not to kiss, trying to not give into sex. Still friends! Acting as though we were trying the relationship on for size–”maybe someday!” Neither wanting to admit: this is it.

Sleeping with someone, again and again, you begin to fall for them. This is just chemistry. Lazing in bed is going through the motions of falling in love. It’s your brain releasing chemicals–your body buzzing on hormones. And if you are compatible–friends– it explodes.

We exchanged the dark pieces of ourselves, necessary in love. “I was 5 and my family was throwing a pool party, I left for a bit, to find my new kittens. I wandered into the garage. There was this awful smell…from the green truck. I got my Dad–he lifted the hood. Inside were the litter of  kittens, melted on the engine. ”  This was me.  Beau told me about having cancer as a teenager –how angry it made him. In the garden, laying on our bellies: “I see  the earth in  your eyes’.

But there were no real declarations. No commitments.  One night out, my ex was there. I left Beau to talk to him and  fell into dancing. The bar was closed and the crowd poured into the street, I was dizzy, my arm in the ex’s grip. Beau stepped in front of us, spikey. “Don’t go home with him”.

The ex grew acidic: “She can make up her own mind.” The crowd in skinny pants held cigarettes in their mouths a little too long. “You are just jealous because I’m a better DJ than you.” They were getting louder now. “You are so not a better DJ!” I spun and started to walk. I heard the first hit. “Oh my god, they are punching each other!” I didn’t turn back, I didn’t want to see.

In the myspace days,there was this feeling that we were all connected though this thing –this scene, these online connections. And in this we were all working towards some greater thing. Whatever this thing was–it ensured that we were okay. Not wanting to see when we weren’t.

It was as though Beau and I didn’t want to see it, didn’t want to touch this thing we had, afraid it would break. But by not seeing, not talking about it–by protecting ourselves in the moment–we were shattering the real relationship we had.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.

7 Comments

  1. Michelle
    Posted 2010-12-29 at 10:21 | Permalink

    This is a beautifully written piece; you did an excellent job.

  2. Posted 2010-12-29 at 11:32 | Permalink

    I’ve been there. GOD have I been there. My story is equally sordid and intensely complicated, so I’ll spare you the details (until we’re sipping on cocktails, of course). But a lot of your story resonated so much with mine. That first time there’s a different kind of touch, trying to fight and suppress those fuzzy feelings, the static between the ex and the “friend.” It’s all a mess.

    But I don’t think it ALWAYS has to be a mess when we sleep with our friends. Both parties need to understand that there is already a deep relationship in play and that there needs to be some kind of communication. In my opinion, the “what does this mean” conversation needs to happen before the sex…but it can definitely wait until after second/third base. ;-)

  3. Posted 2010-12-29 at 11:39 | Permalink

    Thanks Michelle!

    Kait,

    Oh Vey! Why have so many of us been there? It seems it is just too tempting. I assume this is because we all secretly want to do our friends (isn’t that why we started chatting them in the first place?) but anyway. I’m glad this could resonate. In my experience, the problem is totally communication as well. But, I think the prob is that we don’t speak up when “where is this going” changes. We have the talk once and try to stick to what was decided, not being honest as it shifts, and when you sleep together again and again, it most certainly will.

  4. Jerry
    Posted 2010-12-31 at 13:03 | Permalink

    What I can’t quite put my finger on is why these situations seem to almost automatically gravitate in these awkward directions. Maybe it is because there aren’t any ground rules laid out initially, and assumptions crop up in the most unexpected places, like dandelions and such.

  5. Posted 2010-12-31 at 13:13 | Permalink

    Jerry,
    What I think it is is that we often DO lay out ground rules initially (still friends!) but then don’t speak up as the feelings shift and the rules no longer fit.

  6. Jerry
    Posted 2010-12-31 at 13:38 | Permalink

    True enough, now that I think about it a bit more in depth.

  7. Posted 2011-01-1 at 20:56 | Permalink

    you couldn’t have told more truth if you tried. I had a similar situation way back when, and no matter how much I tried to stop them, the feelings just sprang up. It always sneaks up on you don’t it?